Fatal Snowmobile Accident Under Investigation in the Town of Webb

The New York State Police are investigating a fatal snowmobile accident that occurred early yesterday morning on Fourth Lake in the town of Webb.

On February 9, 2025, at approximately 2:52 a.m., State Police from SP Remsen responded to 4920 State Route 28 for reports of a multi-snowmobile collision. Upon arrival, Troopers located Spencer W. Schmidt, 22, of Batavia, NY, who was pronounced deceased at the scene due to injuries sustained in the crash.

Preliminary investigation determined that Schmidt was riding with four friends: Cole Phelps, 26, Carl Stephens, 26, Joshua Boyle, 26, and Zachary Dusky, 26. Dusky was the only rider who avoided the accident, and his snowmobile was undamaged.

Investigators believe the crash involved a disabled, unoccupied snowmobile registered to Eric Butler, 37, which had been left on the lake. Evidence suggests that Schmidt, along with Phelps, Stephens, and Boyle, collided with one another and/or the stationary snowmobile.

Due to the weather conditions and location, all involved parties were evaluated on scene and did not appear to be under the influence of alcohol or drugs. At this time, there is no indication of criminality, and the incident appears to be a tragic accident.

All snowmobiles involved have been transported to SP Carthage for further examination by the State Police Collision Reconstruction Unit and Forensic Investigation Unit.

The investigation remains ongoing.